| Platinum | Tavolino |
| Gold | Sicilian Oven |
| Silver | Pasquale's Pizza & Subs |
| Bronze | Livello |
| Top Pick | Annie's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Incontro Italian Cuisine and Steakhouse |
| Top Pick | Joe's Pizza & Pasta |
| Top Pick | LA Fontana Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Pepperoni Grill Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Pizza Time |