| Platinum | Milanos Bakery |
| Gold | Crocante Cafe & Gourmet Bakery |
| Silver | Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard |
| Bronze | Larry's Ice Cream and Yogurt |
| Top Pick | Cecile's Gourmet Italian Ices |
| Top Pick | Cherry Smash |
| Top Pick | Dairy Queen (Treat) |
| Top Pick | Glyk Gelato |
| Top Pick | Let's Chill Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Whit's Frozen Custard |